In our final installment, The Overtime Heroics Fantasy Hockey squad got together and compiled our own consensus top 20 goalie rankings list. Some players we agreed on, some we were way off on. But that’s the fun of these rankings, you get to see different views on the same players in a fantasy hockey persepctive. For the multi-positional players, we utilized Daily FaceOff’s lineup projections to ensure we didn’t have the same players on multiple lists. Be sure to follow everyone that helped put this list together. @FNTSYHCKYTRADES, @FHFHockey, @JHawreschuk and @penguinhunter.

1. Andrei Vasilevskiy
2018-19 stats: 53 games/53 starts – 39 wins/ 10 losses/ 4 OT losses/ .925 save %/ 2.40 GAA/ 6 shutouts/ 1,713 shots against/ 128 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 1
- FHFHockey – 1
- JHawreschuk – 1
- Penguin Hunter – 1
2. Frederik Andersen
2018-19 stats: 60 games/ 60 starts – 36 wins/ 16 losses/ 7 OT losses/ .917 save %/ 2.77 GAA/ 1 shutout/ 1,958 shots against/ 162 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 3
- FHFHockey – 3
- JHawreshuck – 2
- Penguin Hunter – 3
3. Sergei Bobrovsky
2018-19 stats: 62 games/ 61 starts – 37 wins/ 24 losses/ 1 OT loss/ .913 save %/ 2.58 GAA/ 9 shutouts/ 1,756 shots against/ 153 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 4
- FHFHockey – 2
- JHawreschuk – 3
- Penguin Hunter – 4
4. Ben Bishop
2018-19 stats: 46 games/ 45 starts – 27 wins/ 15 losses/ 2 OT losses/ .934 save %/ 1.98 GAA/ 7 shutouts/ 1,323 shots against/ 87 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 2
- FHFHockey – 5
- JHawreschuk – 6
- Penguin Hunter – 2
5. Tuukka Rask
2018-19 stats: 46 games/ 45 starts – 27 wins/ 13 losses/ 5 OT losses/ .912 save %/ 2.48 GAA/ 1,245 shots against/ 109 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 5
- FHFHockey – 6
- JHawreschuk – 5
- Penguin Hunter – 6
6. Braden Holtby
2018-19 stats: 59 games/ 58 starts – 32 wins/ 19 losses/ 5 OT losses/ .911 save %/ 2.82 GAA/ 1,795 shots against/ 160 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 10
- FHFHockey – 4
- JHawreshcuk – 8
- Penguin Hunter – 5
Tied 7. Marc-Andre Fleury
2018-19 stats: 61 games/ 61 starts – 35 wins/ 21 losses/ 5 OT losses/ .913 save %/ 2.51 GAA/ 1,745 shots against/ 152 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 8
- FHFHockey – 7
- JHawreschuk – 7
- Penguin Hunter – 10
Tied 7. Pekka Rinne
2018-19 stats: 56 games/ 55 starts – 30 wins/ 19 losses/ 4 OT losses/ .918 save %/ 2.42 GAA/ 1,451 shots against/ 130 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 7
- FHFHockey – 8
- JHawreschuk – 9
- Penguin Hunter – 8
9. Carey Price
2018-19 stats: 66 games/ 64 starts – 35 wins/ 24 losses/ 6 OT losses/ .918 save %/ 2.49 GAA/ 1,952 shots against/ 161 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 9
- FHFHockey – 13
- JHawreschuk – 4
- Penguin Hunter – 7
10. Connor Hellebuyck
2018-19 stats: 63 games/ 62 starts – 34 wins/ 23 losses/ 3 OT losses/ .913 save %/ 2.90 GAA/ 2,051 shots against/ 179 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 12
- FHFHockey – 9
- JHawreschuk – 10
- Penguin Hunter – 9
11. John Gibson
2018-19 stats: 58 games/ 57 starts – 26 wins/ 22 losses/ 8 OT losses/ .917 save %/ 2.84 GAA/ 1,838 shots against/ 153 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 6
- FHFHockey – 10
- JHawreschuk – 11
- Penguin Hunter – 17
12. Jordan Binnington
2018-19 stats: 32 games/ 30 starts – 24 wins/ 5 losses/ 1 OT loss/ .927 save %/ 1.89 GAA/ 807 shots against/ 59 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 11
- FHFHockey – 12
- JHawreschuk – 14
- Penguin Hunter – 11
13. Matt Murray
2018-19 stats: 50 games/ 50 starts – 29 wins/ 14 losses/ 6 OT losses/ .919 save %/ 2.69 GAA/ 1,594 shots against/ 129 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 13
- FHFHockey – 11
- JHawreschuk – 12
- Penguin Hunter – 14
14. Philipp Grubauer
2018-19 stats: 37 games/ 33 starts – 18 wins/ 9 losses/ 5 OT losses/ .917 save %/ 2.64 GAA/ 1,071 shots against/ 89 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 15
- FHFHockey – 14
- JHawreschuk – 15
- Penguin Hunter – 13
15. Carter Hart
2018-19 stats: 31 games/ 30 starts – 16 wins/ 13 losses/ 1 OT loss/ .917 save %/ 2.83 GAA/ 976 shots against/ 81 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 14
- FHFHockey – 19
- JHawreschuk – 13
- Penguin Hunter – 15
16. Martin Jones
2018-19 stats: 62 games/ 62 starts – 36 wins/ 19 losses/ 5 OT losses/ .896 save %/ 2.94 GAA/ 3 shutouts/ 1,699 shots against/ 176 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 19
- FHFHockey – 15
- JHawreschuk – 16
- Penguin Hunter – 12
17. Devan Dubnyk
2018-19 stats: 67 games/ 66 starts – 31 wins/ 28 losses/ 6 OT losses/ .913 save %/ 2.54 GAA/ 2 shutouts/ 1,877 shots against/ 163 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 16
- FHFHockey – 17
- JHawreschuk – 18
- Penguin Hunter – 16
18. Antti Raanta
2018-19 stats: 12 games/ 12 starts – 5 wins/ 6 losses/ 0 OT losses/ .906 save %/ 2.88 GAA/ 0 shutouts/ 351 shots against/ 33 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 18
- FHFHockey – 16
- JHawreschuk – 19
- Penguin Hunter – 18
19. Henrik Lundqvist
2018-19 stats: 52 games/ 52 starts – 18 wins/ 23 losses/ 10 OT losses/ .907 save %/ 3.07 GAA/ 0 shutouts/ 1,699 shots against/ 158 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 25
- FHFHockey – 22
- JHawreshuck – 17
- Penguin Hunter – 22
20. Seymon Varlamov
2018-19 stats: 49 games/ 49 starts/ 20 wins/ 19 losses/ 9 OT losses/ .909 save %/ 2.87 GAA/ 2 shutouts/ 1,496 shots against/ 136 goals allowed
- FNTSYHCKYTRADES – 21
- FHFHockey – 18
- JHawreshuck – 27
- Penguin Hunter – 21
We hope you’ve found this series insightful and helpful! As always you can discuss this article and many other on the Overtime Heroics Forums.