Padres Trade Margot and Driscoll to Rays for Emilio Pagan

Image for Padres Trade Margot and Driscoll to Rays for Emilio Pagan

The rumors have come to fruition! After a lot of talk about the Padres potentially dealing their young center fielder, we finally have a trade. The Padres add a much needed bullpen arm in Emilio Pagan, and the Rays get a breakout candidate in Margot. Let’s break it down, piece by piece.

San Diego Padres

The Padres are trading former top prospect and currently struggling outfielder Manuel Margot, along with prospect Logan Driscoll.

Manuel Margot

Margot, as previously mentioned, was a highly-touted prospect who hasn’t exactly lived up to expectations. His defense has been as advertised, as he consistently does well by most defensive metrics. However, it’s the bat that hasn’t been there. In his 3 full seasons in the MLB, he’s compiled a .248 career batting average, and a .695 OPS. That’s hardly what you expect from a guy who was given a 60 grade for his hit tool on the standard 20-80 scale by the MLB. With that said, he’s only 25, and there’s plenty of time for him to turn it around, and develop into the player he was once expected to be.

Logan Driscoll

The prospect in this trade, Logan Driscoll, is a promising young talent. He was picked in the 2nd round, 73rd overall by the Padres last summer in the 2019 MLB Amateur Draft. Driscoll is a catcher who has also seen time at right field, and the name of his game is hitting. He’s a solid contact hitter from the left side, with a .337 batting average in his 3-year NCAA career. He also had good showing in low-A ball after being drafted, hitting .268 and striking out just 23 times in his first 39 professional games. He has a strong arm, but his receiving behind the plate needs work, which is part of why the Padres have experimented with him as an outfielder. His above-average athleticism and speed for a catcher allows for him to be an outfielder if things don’t work out behind the plate.

Tampa Bay Rays

Emilio Pagan

The Rays are giving up one of their better bullpen pieces in Emilio Pagan, who is coming off of a fantastic season. In 2019, he recorded a 2.31 ERA, with an excellent 0.829 WHIP. The Rays have a very deep bullpen which allows them to make this move, but Pagan will absolutely be missed in Tampa Bay. Pagan served as the closer, after Jose Alvarado lost the job due to his struggles to start the year. He used his fastball-cutter combination to rack up 20 saves on the season.


Due to the natural volatility of relief pitchers (looking at you, Edwin Diaz), I think the Rays win this trade. Margot is a top candidate for a breakout season, and Driscoll is a promising young player. With that said, Pagan seems unlikely to regress the way relief pitchers do seemingly out of nowhere. He’s changed his repertoire from 2018 to 2019, effectively cutting his walk rate nearly in half. Only time will tell though, what do you think of this trade, and who do you think won?

Follow me on Twitter at @ArmyOfRasmii and follow us @OT_Heroics for more great content!

Also, be sure to check out the Overtime Heroics Forums page to join in on the discussion!

Check out our partners at Repp Sports! They offer the first-ever crowd-sourced, no carb, no sugar, energy drink called RAZE and much more! Use the link above or add the promo code OTH1 for 30% off at checkout!

Share this article