You are here
Home > Baseball > Analytics Didn’t Ruin Baseball; Nostalgia Did

Analytics Didn’t Ruin Baseball; Nostalgia Did

Baseball is a sport that is losing the coveted status it always had as America’s Pastime. This has caused baseball fans to wonder what went wrong. After the end of the steroid era, Major League Baseball hit a downturn for the worst. The rise of analytics coincided with this fall, and as baseball ratings plummet, they get the blame. In baseball, analytics have become been villanized.

“The good old days of baseball” is a phrase used often. People say Kevin Cash ruined the day by pulling Blake Snell in Game 6. Whatever excuse is offered, this is objectively wrong. Analytics didn’t ruin baseball, it’s the nostalgia that people use to bash the modern game that has ruined it.

Analytics Lead To Winning

The most analytical teams in baseball over the last half-decade are some of baseball’s BEST teams. The Rays, Dodgers, Astros, Red Sox, Yankees, A’s and Cubs have combined for tons of wins over the last five years. They’ve also had a lot of postseason success, with the Rays, Dodgers, Astros, Red Sox and Cubs all winning pennants.

The formula has created production at its peak efficiency and has made up for gaps in talent. The Dodgers and Rays went 6 games in the World Series, despite the Dodgers’ roster being MUCH more loaded. Analytics has created a way to get the best out of players, and it’s been conducive towards winning.

Bashing Analytics Hurts Baseball

A-Rod going on national television to bash analytics is a joke. The dude just watched the “Ivy Leaguers” dismantle the Yankees. It was a literal beatdown throughout the entire 2020 season. He just saw Dodgers’ GM Andrew Friedman (who brought analytics to the Rays) win a World Series as well. Baseball is being painted as an evil sport where idiots are running the show. Analytical teams have consistently brought forth a product worth watching in terms of consistent success for their fans. When you ignorantly call them a form of cancer to baseball, you make the entire sport look bad.

Other Sports Have Become Extremely Analytical

Basketball had the three-point revolution that dramatically changed the sport, and it is as popular as ever. The NFL is a league where the running back has been determined by analytics as not super valuable. Passing is everything, and it’s the most popular sport in America. The problem with baseball isn’t that the game is more efficient for teams, because if it was, then we’d see other sports become less popular as well.

“Only Hitting Home Runs” Isn’t New

I always hear about the good old days when in the 90s “real hitters” would play. Wasn’t that the same era of baseball that had steroids? The same era where Barry Bonds would quite literally only walk and hit home runs? Sammy Sosa and Mark McGuire aren’t lambasted by people like A-Rod who hate analytics.

How is it that we look upon an era of home runs as the era in which hitters were at their best, yet look at today’s home run clobberers as bad for the game? It’s called nostalgia. It makes everything in the past feel better than it actually was. Baseball doesn’t have a home run problem or an analytics problem, it has a nostalgia problem.

Making Productive Changes in Baseball

Are analytics 100% right? Obviously, they aren’t always right, but they’re a model that is more right than wrong, so teams will follow them. You can’t be mad with the sport of baseball for wanting to win. Let’s actually talk about the things with the sport which are wrong. Things like the lack of marketability and the outdated “unwritten rules”. Analytics isn’t going to be the reason the sport loses viewers.

Next time you hear some national media pundit blame the lack of ratings on analytics, now you know; analytics isn’t ruining baseball, your nostalgia is.

Have a baseball lover that you need to get a gift for? Check out our partner at Dugout Mugs! Create a personalized mug made out of the barrel of a bat. Great for any baseball fan, or, let’s be honest, yourself!

Follow me on Twitter at @RyanGarciaESM for more of my content! Don’t forget to join our OT Heroics MLB Facebook group, and feel free to join our new Instagram –  @overtimeheroics_MLB, and listen to our baseball podcast, Cheap Seat Chatter!. We’ll see ya there!
Come join the discussion made by the fans at the Overtime Heroics forums! A place for all sports!

Similar Articles

2 thoughts on “Analytics Didn’t Ruin Baseball; Nostalgia Did

  1. Making it where you cannot block the plate the infielder rule where in filters can interfere with the runner to try and get a double play when before the game was pure like Homer Doubleday intended it the home plate is the final defense the catcher should be able to block the runner and before it was infielders turn a double play at your own risk plus you have the designated hitter what kind of team leader is that has to have someone hit for him while he hides in The dugout the two leaders never even meet during the game

  2. The A’s have nothing to show for the use of it other than getting in the playoffs and stalling. The teams who do use it and win have money. Then there are the sell your soul teams. Marlins and recently the Royals. There are no analytics that can keep Lindor in Cleveland. Analytics was developed by teams with small budgets so they can get a lot more bang of their buck.

    The dodgers saw that and say cool then went and gave Mookie Betts a ton of money. In real life and in sports brains and money will beat out brains and some money.

    Also every it seems every year like this one in the NFL scoring is up. Not in MLB. Three and half hour games with barely any base runners and a few hits with twenty K’s aesthetically is boring.

    And I’m a huge baseball fan.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: