In a move that left many NFL fans and analysts stunned, the Atlanta Falcons made a surprising decision in the 2024 NFL Draft. Despite expectations of bolstering their defense, the Falcons opted to select a quarterback, choosing Washington’s Michael Penix Jr. over highly touted prospect J.J. McCarthy from Michigan.
The choice caught even veteran quarterback Kirk Cousins off guard. Cousins, who recently signed a lucrative four-year, $180 million contract with the Falcons, reportedly anticipated the team drafting a quarterback but didn’t anticipate it being a first-round pick with the potential to challenge his position. Comparing the contracts of Cousins and Penix reveals an interesting overlap. While the specifics of Penix’s rookie deal aren’t disclosed, it’s expected to surpass the approximately $22 million four-year contract signed by last year’s No. 8 pick, Bijan Robinson. Penix’s contract will likely extend through the 2027 season, with the Falcons holding a fifth-year option.
Falcons GM Terry Fontenot explaining why they selected Michael Penix Jr. to owner Arthur Blank 🫣pic.twitter.com/lFtc1neHl5 https://t.co/GMGYgaCnok
— Dov Kleiman (@NFL_DovKleiman) April 26, 2024
However, there are concerns surrounding Penix’s age and injury history. At 23 years old and turning 24 by Week 1 of the upcoming season, he’s older than typical first-round quarterback picks. Additionally, he has a history of significant injuries, including two ACL tears. Despite playing the last two seasons injury-free, these factors raise questions about his long-term durability and performance.
"IT DOESN'T MAKE ANY SENSE"
lmaooo the Falcons drafting Michael Penix Jr. had our draft guys shook. pic.twitter.com/l3qh6ApQg8
— #RingerNFL (@ringernfl) April 26, 2024
Looking ahead, Penix will be 28 by the end of his rookie contract, potentially making his fifth-year option a costly gamble if he hasn’t secured a starting role. With uncertainties surrounding Penix’s health and development, the Falcons’ bold move could either signal a new era under center or lead to financial and strategic challenges down the line.
